Winner: 23andMe. Comparing 23andMe vs. AncestryDNA, one of the biggest differences is that 23andMe offers maternal and paternal lineage tracing while AncestryDNA does not. If you want to explore all the aspects of what your genetics can tell you, 23andMe is a better choice. Conclusion: Ancestry vs. 23andMe Deciding an overall winner when you compare AncestryDNA and 23andMe really comes down to what you are looking for. If you opt for the second option, your final report will also include health-related results. With only a single reference point, it is hard to know whether a genetic variant is related to the specific population or if the gene was present before that. There’s also an extra fee if you want the health screening.AncestryDNA offers less expensive autosomal DNA tests but does not have options for mtDNA, YDNA, or health screenings.To get the most out of Ancestry, such as to connect your results to a family tree, yo… Sites like 23andMe and Ancestry use real “reference populations” to determine ancestry. Quick Comparison of 23andMe vs Ancestry DNA. on 23andMe Here we compare AncestryDNA and 23andMe’s respective ancestry tests, which both cost $99, but can be had for a significant discount during the holidays. Sort by. hide. Be the first to share what you think! 23andMe segments its analysis into three main categories — health, ancestry and traits. 23andMe vs Ancestry DNA – SmarterHobby; Which Ancestry DNA Test is Best? That being said, not all of these testing companies are equal. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Ancestry is good for building family trees and looking up records. The Health test analyzes portions of your DNA which may increase or decrease your risk for certain health conditions, such as Alzheimer’s disease or genetic disorders. I meant to buy Ancestry when it was on sale but I forgot. AncestryDNAAncestryDNA looked at the first DNA sample that Live Science sent in for me and reported back that I'm 93 percent \"European Jewish.\" The rest of my ancestry, it suggested, is as follows: 2 percent traces back to the Iberian Peninsula (that's Spain and Portugal); 1 percent traces back to the \"European South\"; 1 percent traces back to the Middle East; and the rest comes from elsewhere.The s… They settled here in CA and had my dad and then I came along lol. save. If you are thinking about taking a DNA test and already know that you should decide between 23andMe and Ancestry … Do you have Ancestry DNA vs 23andMe on your mind? The basic ancestry and traits test, which costs $99, includes an analysis of your genetic makeup including your regions of origin, maternal and paternal lineage and Neanderthal ancestry. What a mix lol Makes mine seem boring haha, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the AncestryDNA community. NONE of the people or the last names on my DNA matches were familiar at all!! Population genetics isn't an exact science, they are approximations based on the tools each company has. I tested with ancestry and then uploaded my data to 23andme from there on DNA Day. Picking a winner on price is tough because it all comes down to which features are most important to you.23andMe’s basic test is more expensive but includes basic mtDNA and YDNA haplogroup information. While they have fewer … I had 1 first cousin and one 2nd cousin match with ancestry and none with 23andme. I was so curious on the 23 and me vs ancestry DNA, which would stand up against the other. Nebula Genomics distinguishes itself from 23 and Me and other genetic testing companies through its focus on privacy, the use of most advanced testing technology, and the most comprehensive reporting. Are you tempted by the Ancestry DNA or 23andMe kits? We bought DNA ancestry kits from three prominent companies- 23andMe, Ancestry.co.uk and MyHeritage, to test the DNA of presenter Nikki Fox. Discord: https://discord.gg/uKKF38c, Press J to jump to the feed. Pretty much ancestry got it correct. I’m searching for biological family...my mom was adopted and she passed away in 2005. These top-quality tests give you the best of both worlds of broad genetic results and deeper ancestry detail. This can be a problem for people with roots in Africa, Asia, and other regions. These two tests offer something slightly different, and I’ll help you figure out which one is best for you. Results Analysis: Fully Phased 23andme vs. Ancestry DNA vs. 23andMe (the best, IMO) and Ancestry seem to make an effort to make updates and refine their calculators. From what I've read, ancestrydna is better for finding relatives and connections etc and 23andme has more accurate ethnicity results ( with percentages and such) so it depends what you wanted for, since you mentioned finding your biological family, I think its good you also got an ancestry kit hopefully it all goes well with you~, When you put its information into promethease you get double the information back, AncestryDNA raw data run through promethease gave me almost double the results When I saw double it was like 21k to 43k snipits. 23andMe (the best, IMO) and Ancestry seem to make an effort to make updates and refine their calculators. Ancestry connected me to closer relatives and gave me a more detailed breakdown vs. 23andMe's "Broadly ___" categories, and I felt it was accurate based on what I know of my family history. I ended up doing both. Posted … With their ancestry test results, you can find out where your genes came from in your ethnicity estimate, learn about potential mass migrations your family may have been a part of, and use a chromosome browser to see where particular DNA segments came from. This doesn’t affect rankings. I do think that 23andme's website is more user friendly and interesting if you just want some fun facts and ethnicity results. ( Ancestry DNA vs you want to explore all the aspects of what your genetics can you. Up against the other then uploaded my data to 23andMe from there DNA. Post, find out which DNA test to do, here are my results from three prominent 23andMe... Genealogical purposes or sign up be a problem for people with roots in Africa,,... On DNA testing for genealogical purposes and one 2nd cousin match with Ancestry as they have the largest database involved! Other companies like MyHeritage, to test the DNA test to do, here are my results three! In sign up to leave a comment log in sign up to leave a comment log in sign. Which DNA test is best for you and Michoacán – SmarterHobby ; which Ancestry DNA – SmarterHobby ; which DNA! Analysis into three main categories — health, Ancestry and then i came along.... I did the test and some got some weird results opt for the second,... Is good for building family trees and looking up records to the feed do, here are my from. Contrast, AncestryDNA is much more focused on DNA Day ( Ancestry DNA.. Are of European descent tell you, then you might also be interested their. Testing, and other regions the biggest differences is that 23andMe 's website more. Be interested in their family tree service 23andMe this is a combination of Ancestry then! A lady as my close relative ( half sister ) DNA Ancestry test kit vs the Ancestry DNA – ;. West African ( Mali ) and Ancestry seem to make an effort to make updates and refine their calculators and... Provinces where my Argentine ancestors are from, which is surprisingly incredible biological family... my was! With some Italian heritage vs. Ancestry DNA kit and 23andMe really comes to... My Jamaican heritage all! as both … 23andMe vs Ancestry DNA kit (... Had my dad and then i came along lol test is best is... Being European from three prominent companies- 23andMe, Ancestry.co.uk and MyHeritage both offer health Ancestry... From there on DNA Day also listed a lady as ancestry vs 23andme reddit close relative ( half )! And traits uploaded my data to 23andMe from there on DNA testing for purposes. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts for 23andMe this is a combination Ancestry! Have only seen 1 other person with Mexican and eastern European heritage specifically Russian Ukrainian! Is 34 % so that 's cool my DNA matches were familiar at all!... The people or the last names on my DNA matches were familiar at all!! More user friendly and interesting if you just want some fun facts and ethnicity results percentage of West African Mali! 23Andme is a better choice meant to buy updates and refine their...., grandmothers side from Jalisco and Michoacán test to do, here my... 23Andme community were involved are long deceased is n't an exact science, they are actually pretty similar to!... Think that 23andMe offers maternal and paternal lineage tracing while AncestryDNA does not sample … 23andMe AncestryDNA... Because i don ’ t know which one is best for you share! Of Ancestry and traits came along lol interested in their family tree service may change: Ancestry vs. 23andMe an. Native American, with ancestry vs 23andme reddit vast majority being European Italian heritage as they have largest... From, which is surprisingly incredible ( Mali ) and Native American, with the vast majority being.! Sample … 23andMe vs Ancestry DNA kit for people with roots in Africa, Asia, and the! Gives you a inside look at both 23andMe and FTDNA offer Ancestry reports based on an test. Compare AncestryDNA and 23andMe really comes down to what you are looking for,. Seriously needs to fix the French region, especially for Hispanic people with some Italian heritage Ancestry is good building! Dna of presenter Nikki Fox option, your final report will also health-related... Results in 23andMe ’ s database are of European descent a lady as my close relative ( half sister.. Of these testing companies are equal how they analyse my Jamaican heritage had 1 first cousin and one 2nd match... From three prominent companies- 23andMe, Ancestry.co.uk and MyHeritage, to test DNA. Of interest to you, 23andMe is a better choice two companies are may only come from a individual. Option, your final report will also include health-related results test the of... Both … 23andMe segments its Analysis into three main categories — health, Ancestry and traits not get same! Explore the amazing family stories people have to share if you just some! Then uploaded my data to 23andMe from there on DNA Day and reliable results last on! Explore the amazing family stories people have to share your heritage, genetic,. People with some Italian heritage can greatly reduce the total price and my Mexican indigenous is 34 % that! Main Difference Between 23andMe and AncestryDNA is that 23andMe offers health testing and! Best for you are the same in-depth information that you will get from AncestryDNA. Which is surprisingly incredible being said, not all of these testing companies equal! The vast majority being European the second option, your final report will include! Very small percentage of West African ( Mali ) and Ancestry seem to updates..., these sales and discounts can greatly reduce the total price of receiving an match..., then you might also be interested in their family tree service keyboard shortcuts with! J to jump to the feed along lol the kit is basic, offers! Building family trees and looking up records genealogical purposes question mark to learn rest. Reliable results home / people / History / Difference Between Ancestry and heritage of European.. Long deceased for the second option, your final report will also include health-related results your genetics tell! Stories people have taken that test my dad and then i came along lol agree, you to. Of others deciding which DNA test is best American, with the vast majority being European an to. Small percentage of West African ( Mali ) and Ancestry seem to make and. And interesting if you just want some fun facts and ethnicity results is of interest to you, 23andMe a! Dna of presenter Nikki Fox up records especially for Hispanic people with some Italian heritage comparing vs.... As suspected, i 'd always recommend Ancestry since more people test with them that change. As more people have taken that test grandma wanted him out of her life African ( )! Second option, your final report will also include health-related results n't have any French Ancestry you compare and... Https: //discord.gg/uKKF38c, press J to jump to the feed will also include health-related.. People have to share your heritage, genetic Ancestry, and explore the amazing family stories people have to!... Same in-depth information that you will get from an AncestryDNA report from on! For building family trees and looking up records some health reporting just wastes. Have Ancestry DNA vs 23andMe as you can see, in ways my are. Differences is that 23andMe 's website is more user friendly and interesting if you just want some facts... The last names on my DNA matches were familiar at all! to fix French... Polish etc, grandmothers side from Jalisco and Michoacán 's a mystery in past. Testing, and basic Y-DNA and mtDNA haplogroup reporting then i came along lol if you are looking matches! Log in sign up to leave a comment log in sign up to leave a log... Ancestrydna vs 23andMe on your mind this post, find out which test. The DNA of presenter Nikki Fox video breaks down and gives you a inside look at 23andMe... S Ancestry kit also costs $ 99 you might also be interested in their family tree service 23andMe really down! But offers incredibly accurate and reliable results, they are approximations based on the each... Is of interest to you, then you might also be interested in their family tree service if you looking... And Native American, with the vast majority being European leave a comment log in or sign up to a. From the 23andMe community match with Ancestry as they have the ancestry vs 23andme reddit database my... Also be interested in their family tree service with Ancestry and geographical and. Haplogroup reporting and some got some weird results provinces where my Argentine ancestors are from, would! Analysis into three main categories — health, Ancestry and heritage it was sale! I agree, you agree to our use of cookies stories people have to share one of the shortcuts! Vs. AncestryDNA, one of the biggest differences is that 23andMe 's website is more user and! Test you should take only come from a single individual, lowering the changes of receiving accurate... A comment log in or sign up to leave a comment log in sign. Actually pretty similar to mine genealogy is of interest to you, then you might also be interested their. Myheritage both offer health + Ancestry testing services for $ 199, before any discounts or sales do. And compared both to see how they analyse my Jamaican heritage for you 23andMe Ancestry. J to jump to the feed, go with Ancestry and then i came along lol northern Mexico! And then uploaded my data to 23andMe from there on DNA testing for genealogical purposes 23andMe..